AI Hallucination Cases: The 2,202-Case Sanctions Tracker
2,202 court decisions now involve AI-fabricated citations, per the Charlotin database (Oct 2026). Sanctions by country, the growth curve and how to avoid them.
Key facts
- 2,202 decisions worldwide involving hallucinated AI material (Charlotin database, updated 19 October 2026).
- By country: United States 1,501; Canada 234; Australia 112; United Kingdom 76; Brazil 41; India 16; Italy 15; France 14; Argentina 10; Singapore 8 (Charlotin database jurisdiction filter, 19 October 2026).
- By filer: pro se litigants 1,267; lawyers 872; judges 32; experts 17 (Charlotin database party filter, 19 October 2026).
- Growth: about 200 cases in mid-2025, 719 in January 2026 (Scientific American, 2026), 1,227 in early April 2026 (PlatinumIDS, April 2026), 1,458 on 22 May, 1,598 on 9 June, 2,046 on 21 September and 2,202 on 19 October 2026 (HAQQ checks of the live database).
- Largest single-matter penalty we can source: about $109,700 in sanctions and fees in Couvrette v. Wisnovsky, D. Oregon (ABA Journal, 2026).
- US courts imposed over $145,000 in AI-filing penalties in Q1 2026 (ComplexDiscovery, April 2026).
- Withers v. City of Aberdeen, N.D. Mississippi, 8 June 2026: fake citations on both sides, trial canceled, two lead attorneys suspended from the district for two years (Bloomberg Law, June 2026).
- Paid legal research tools hallucinated on 17% (Lexis+ AI) to 33% or more (Westlaw AI-Assisted Research) of benchmark queries (Stanford RegLab and HAI, Journal of Empirical Legal Studies, 2025).
How many AI hallucination cases are there?
2,202, as of the database's 19 October 2026 update. The database is maintained by Damien Charlotin, a research fellow at HEC Paris. Its inclusion bar is strict: a decision is listed only where a court or tribunal found, or clearly implied, that a party relied on hallucinated material. Accusations alone do not count.
We check the number ourselves each month rather than quoting secondary coverage. On 22 May 2026 the count was 1,458. On 9 June it was 1,598, a pace of just under eight new cases a day. Between 9 June and 21 September the pace fell to about 4.3 a day (2,046). Between 21 September and 19 October it picked up again to about 5.6 a day (2,202).
Two caveats on reading the number. First, it counts only what a judge caught and wrote up; a fake citation nobody checks never reaches the database, so 2,202 is a floor. Second, most entries are not lawyers. Self-represented litigants account for 1,267 of the decisions and lawyers for 872. The lawyer cases are the ones that produce sanctions, suspensions and regulator referrals, and they are the ones this page tracks in detail.
How fast is the count growing?
| Mid-2025 | ~200 |
| January 2026 | 719 |
| Early April 2026 | 1,227 |
| 22 May 2026 (our audit) | 1,458 |
| 9 June 2026 | 1,598 |
| 21 September 2026 | 2,046 |
| 19 October 2026 (latest) | 2,202 |
May, June, September and October figures are HAQQ's own checks against the live database. The implied rate over the latest window is about 5.6 new cases per day.
Scientific American (2026) put the database at about 200 cases a year earlier and 719 in January 2026. PlatinumIDS counted 1,227 in April 2026, 811 of them in US courts. Our four checks since May extend the same line. The daily rate moves around from month to month, but it has not gone below four.
Which lawyers have been sanctioned for AI fake citations?
The table below lists the decisions we treat as landmarks, verified against the judgment or primary reporting. Read top to bottom, it shows the penalty arc: a fine in 2023, fee awards and revoked admissions in 2025, then suspensions, a canceled trial and personal costs against supervising lawyers by 2026.
| Case | Court | Year | Penalty |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mata v. Avianca | S.D.N.Y. (US) | 2023 | $5,000 fine |
| Wadsworth v. Walmart | D. Wyoming (US) | 2025 | $3,000 fine for drafter, $1,000 each for 2 signers, pro hac vice revoked |
| R (Ayinde) v Haringey [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin) | Divisional Court (England and Wales) | 2025 | Contempt threshold met; referral to the Bar Standards Board |
| Coomer v. Lindell | D. Colorado (US) | 2025 | $3,000 each for 2 lawyers |
| Acevedo c/ Caceres Mareco | Cámara de Apelación Civil y Comercial de Morón, Sala I (Argentina) | 2025 | Appeal declared deserted; warning; bar referral |
| M.J.L. c/ Peugeot Citroen Argentina | Cámara de Apelaciones de General Roca (Argentina) | 2025 | Warning to both sides; bar referral |
| UK v SSHD [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC) | Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum Chamber (UK) | 2025 (reported 2026) | One solicitor referred to the SRA; one had self-reported |
| Couvrette v. Wisnovsky | D. Oregon (US) | 2025 | About $109,700 in sanctions and fees |
| Tan Hai Peng Micheal v Tan Cheong Joo [2026] SGHC 49 | High Court (Singapore) | 2026 | S$5,000 personal costs each against counsel and the assisting solicitor |
| Whiting v. City of Athens | 6th Circuit (US) | 2026 | $15,000 each for 2 lawyers, plus fees and double costs |
| Withers v. City of Aberdeen | N.D. Mississippi (US) | 2026 | Trial canceled; 2-year district suspensions; fines of $1,000 to $3,500 for every lawyer of record |
How do courts treat AI hallucinations by jurisdiction?
Courts in the United States, England and Wales, Singapore and Argentina reached the same rule without coordinating: the lawyer who files a document must check every authority in it, and that duty cannot be handed to a tool, a junior or a vendor. Where they differ is in who pays and how much.
United States: from fines to careers
US courts produce most of the database (1,501 of 2,202 decisions) and most of the money. Mata v. Avianca (S.D.N.Y., June 2023) set the reference point: six invented cases from ChatGPT, a $5,000 fine. In Wadsworth v. Walmart (D. Wyoming, February 2025), eight of nine citations came from Morgan & Morgan's in-house platform, MX2.law, and did not exist; the drafting lawyer lost his pro hac vice admission (LawSites, 2025). Branding a tool as legal AI did not move the verification duty off the lawyer.
In Coomer v. Lindell (D. Colorado, July 2025), a brief with nearly 30 defective citations cost each of two lawyers $3,000 (NPR, 2025). In Couvrette v. Wisnovsky (D. Oregon), 15 fake citations and eight fabricated quotations across three summary judgment briefs produced about $109,700 in combined sanctions and fees, which the magistrate judge called "a notorious outlier in both degree and volume" (ABA Journal, 2026).
Appellate courts then raised the ceiling. In Whiting v. City of Athens, the Sixth Circuit found more than 24 fake citations, ordered two lawyers to pay $15,000 each in punitive sanctions under Federal Rule of Appellate Procedure 38, plus the other side's fees and double costs (Sixth Circuit Appellate Blog, 2026). On 8 June 2026, in Withers v. City of Aberdeen, Judge Sharion Aycock canceled a trial after both sides filed nonexistent cases, suspended the two lead out-of-state lawyers from the Northern District of Mississippi for two years, revoked pro hac vice admissions and notified state bars (Bloomberg Law, 2026).
England and Wales: the authoritative-source rule
In R (Ayinde) v London Borough of Haringey, heard with Al-Haroun v Qatar National Bank, the Divisional Court (the President of the King's Bench Division and Johnson J) handed down [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin) on 6 June 2025. Five fake cases in a homelessness judicial review brought a junior barrister before the court. The court found the threshold for contempt was met, declined to start proceedings that time, and referred her to the Bar Standards Board (Burges Salmon, 2025).
"Freely available generative artificial intelligence tools... are not capable of conducting reliable legal research." (R (Ayinde) v Haringey [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin))
The judgment also listed what counts as an authoritative source: the government's legislation database, the National Archives database of judgments, the official Law Reports and the databases of reputable legal publishers. That list is a practical specification for any research tool a barrister relies on.
The Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) went further on supervision in UK v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC), promulgated 17 November 2025. Under its Hamid jurisdiction it held that a supervising lawyer remains responsible for the accuracy of delegated work and must make sure fee-earners understand the risks of non-specialist AI. It referred one solicitor to the Solicitors Regulation Authority; the other had already self-reported. It also warned that uploading confidential documents to an open-source tool such as ChatGPT can breach confidentiality and waive privilege, and should be referred to the Information Commissioner's Office.
Singapore: personal costs for both lawyers
In Tan Hai Peng Micheal v Tan Cheong Joo [2026] SGHC 49 (judgment dated 6 March 2026), S Mohan J dealt with two fictitious cases in the defendants' closing submissions. Counsel Goh Peck San filed them; solicitor Amarjit Singh Sidhu, brought in to help with research, had supplied them. The court held that counsel's duty to verify was non-delegable, ordered S$5,000 in personal costs against each of them on an indemnity basis, refused to deal with the issue privately, and barred both from charging their clients for the time spent on it.
Argentina: warnings and bar referrals at appellate level
Argentina has 10 decisions in the database. The appellate rulings we could verify end in warnings and referrals to the local bar; none imposed a fine. In M.J.L. c/ Peugeot Citroen Argentina, the General Roca civil appeals chamber found nonexistent citations in both sides' briefs, imposed no sanction, issued a formal warning and referred the matter to the Colegio de Abogados de General Roca. In Acevedo c/ Caceres Mareco, Sala I of the Morón civil and commercial appeals chamber declared the appeal deserted because its grounds rested on citations nobody could locate, and also referred the matter to the bar (Marval O'Farrell Mairal, October 2025).
A Rosario appeals chamber (Sala II, August 2025) took the same preventive line, calling the lawyer's conduct good faith but describing unverified delegation of case-law research as reckless while the tools still hallucinate (Diario Judicial, 2025). The procedural consequence is the one Argentine lawyers feel: an appeal built on fake authority fails the concrete-critique requirement and is lost.
United Arab Emirates: the Gulf's first AI costs order
In Arabyads Holding Ltd v Gulrez Alam [2025] ADGMCFI 0032, decided in December 2025, the ADGM Court of First Instance ordered the defendant's former lawyers to pay AED 282,508 in wasted costs, on an indemnity basis. Their defence relied on non-existent or misapplied authorities, and the court called the failure to verify AI-generated research reckless and a breach of the ADGM Rules of Conduct (Matouk Bassiouny & Hennawy; Morgan Lewis). How the three UAE court systems treat AI is in Onshore, DIFC, ADGM.
How have AI sanctions escalated?
| Mata v. Avianca (2023) | $5,000 |
| Whiting v. City of Athens (2026), punitive sanctions | $30,000 |
| Couvrette v. Wisnovsky (2025-26), combined | ~$109,700 |
Withers v. City of Aberdeen (June 2026) carried smaller fines but added two-year suspensions and a canceled trial, which no dollar bar captures.
The money matters less than the other consequences. The 2025 and 2026 decisions add revoked admissions, regulator referrals, a contempt finding, a canceled trial, district suspensions and personal costs against the lawyer who signed without checking. A fine ends a bad week. A two-year suspension from a federal district ends a practice there.
Why do lawyers keep filing fake AI citations?
Base rates explain most of it. Stanford RegLab's study found that purpose-built paid research tools hallucinated on 17% (Lexis+ AI) to 33% or more (Westlaw AI-Assisted Research) of its benchmark queries, and an earlier Stanford study found general chatbots wrong on 69% to 88% of legal queries. Our own 300-task benchmark of frontier models found 24% of graded answers cited or applied law that did not support the point (HAQQ ran that benchmark and sells a legal AI product, so weigh our numbers accordingly). A tool that is wrong one time in four, used daily by busy lawyers, fills this database on schedule.
The rest is delegation. Wadsworth shows a firm platform inventing eight of nine cites. UKUT 81 and SGHC 49 show the person who signed relying on someone else to have checked. Every jurisdiction above landed on the same answer: the signature carries the duty.
How can lawyers avoid AI citation sanctions?
- Open every cited authority in a primary source (official reports, court databases, legislation portals) before filing. A citation that only exists in the AI output is a fake until proven otherwise.
- Check that the passage says what the brief claims. Several sanctioned briefs cited real cases for propositions they never stated.
- Put the check at signature. Supervisors in the UK and Singapore were held responsible for work they delegated and did not check.
- Keep confidential documents out of consumer chatbots; the Upper Tribunal treats that as a confidentiality and privilege problem.
- Prefer tools that retrieve and cite sources you can click over tools that answer from memory, and keep a record of what was verified.
This is how we built HAQQ's legal research: Justinian retrieves the source, cites it, and flags when it cannot find support, and material work routes to a lawyer before it leaves the firm. That narrows the gap and leaves the duty to check with the lawyer.
For a step-by-step version you can adopt as firm policy, see The Maker Cannot Be the Checker: A Verification Protocol for Legal AI.
How is this tracker kept current?
Once a month we re-read the live database and primary reporting and check four things: the total count, the largest sourced penalty, new landmark decisions (appellate, cross-border or a new kind of sanction) and the implied daily rate. A number we cannot re-verify comes off the page.
- 20 October 2026: count updated from 2,046 to 2,202 (database update of 19 October), +156 in 28 days, about 5.6 a day. Added country and filer breakdowns. Folded in our earlier jurisdiction report: UKUT 81, verified SGHC 49 orders (S$5,000 each), and the Argentine appellate decisions (warnings and bar referrals). Corrected the Wadsworth fine breakdown.
- 21 September 2026: count updated from 1,598 to 2,046, +448 in 104 days, about 4.3 a day.
- 11 June 2026: rebuilt as a tracker. Count updated from 1,458 to 1,598. Added Couvrette, Whiting, Withers, Wadsworth, Coomer, Ayinde and Tan Hai Peng.
- 22 May 2026: original audit published at 1,458 cases.
General legal information, not legal advice; check the rules of the court and regulator you appear before.
Sources and further reading
- Damien Charlotin: AI Hallucination Cases database
- R (Ayinde) v Haringey and Al-Haroun v QNB [2025] EWHC 1383 (Admin), Judiciary of England and Wales
- UK v SSHD [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC), National Archives
- Tan Hai Peng Micheal v Tan Cheong Joo [2026] SGHC 49, eLitigation
- Marval O'Farrell Mairal: Argentine courts warn over fake AI citations
- ABA Journal: Oregon federal judge hands down $110K penalty for AI errors
- Bloomberg Law: lawyers on both sides in Mississippi case punished for AI errors
- Sixth Circuit Appellate Blog: sanctions for fake citations in Whiting v. City of Athens
- LawSites: Morgan & Morgan attorneys sanctioned in Wadsworth v. Walmart
- NPR: AI hallucination in Mike Lindell case
- Burges Salmon: professional conduct and AI in Ayinde v Haringey
- Scientific American: why lawyers keep citing fake cases invented by AI
- ComplexDiscovery: the AI sanction wave, $145K in Q1 penalties
- PlatinumIDS: inside the AI hallucination crisis hitting courts
- Stanford HAI / RegLab: legal models hallucinate 1 out of 6 queries or more
- Our fake-citation search experiment
- Can lawyers use AI? Bar rules country by country
- Our 300-task frontier model benchmark (the 24% citation gap)
- AI and client confidentiality for lawyers
FAQ
How many AI hallucination cases are there?
2,202 court and tribunal decisions as of 19 October 2026, per Damien Charlotin's AI Hallucination Cases database. It lists only decisions where a court found or clearly implied reliance on hallucinated material, so the true number is higher. US courts account for 1,501 of them.
How many AI hallucination cases involve lawyers rather than self-represented litigants?
872 of the 2,202 decisions involve lawyers and 1,267 involve pro se litigants, per the database's party filter on 19 October 2026. A smaller number involve judges (32), experts (17) and prosecutors (5).
What is the largest sanction for AI fake citations?
The largest single-matter penalty we can source is about $109,700 in combined sanctions and fees in Couvrette v. Wisnovsky (D. Oregon), where counsel filed 15 fake citations and eight fabricated quotations across three briefs (ABA Journal, 2026).
Can a lawyer be suspended for citing fake AI cases?
Yes. In Withers v. City of Aberdeen (N.D. Mississippi, June 2026) the judge suspended two lead attorneys from practising in the district for two years and canceled the trial. Courts also revoke pro hac vice admissions and refer lawyers to regulators, as in Ayinde v Haringey (Bar Standards Board) and UK v SSHD [2026] UKUT 81 (Solicitors Regulation Authority).
Is a supervising lawyer liable for a junior's AI hallucinations?
Courts in England and Singapore say yes. The Upper Tribunal in [2026] UKUT 81 (IAC) held that supervisors remain responsible for the accuracy of delegated work. In Tan Hai Peng v Tan Cheong Joo [2026] SGHC 49, the Singapore High Court ordered S$5,000 in personal costs against both the counsel who filed fictitious cases and the solicitor who supplied them.
How do lawyers avoid sanctions when using AI?
Open every cited authority in a primary source before filing, confirm the passage says what the brief claims, do the check at signature rather than relying on whoever drafted, keep confidential documents out of consumer chatbots, and prefer tools that cite retrievable sources over tools that answer from memory.
Which court cases have involved sanctions for AI hallucinations in legal filings?
The clearest Gulf example is Arabyads Holding Ltd v Gulrez Alam [2025] ADGMCFI 0032. In December 2025 the ADGM Court of First Instance ordered the defendant's former legal representatives to pay AED 282,508 in wasted costs, on an indemnity basis, for filing unverified AI-assisted research. As in other AI sanctions cases, the problem was the failure to verify, not the use of AI.